Nino's NY Pizzeria

Nino's NY Pizzeria at 8889 S Seneca St Weedsport, NY 13166 serves up authentic New York-style pizza that’s got the locals talking and travelers making detours. If you’re searching for where to eat in Weedsport or craving real-deal thin crust, this is your place.

Nino's NY Pizzeria brings New York flavors to Weedsport

It’s hard to miss the buzz around Nino's NY Pizzeria, especially if you’re in or around Weedsport. This spot has become something of a local landmark, with a reputation for pizza that rivals what you’d find in Manhattan. Walk in, and you’ll be greeted by the aroma of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese—a scent that hits just right after a long day or mid-road trip on the Thruway.

Locals say it’s the crust that keeps them coming back. Thin but sturdy, with that signature snap when folded, it’s exactly what New York pizza should be. Then there’s the sauce—zesty, balanced, and clearly homemade, paired with generous toppings from classic pepperoni to roasted garlic and ricotta. But Nino’s isn’t just about pizza. Their menu also includes subs, pastas, and crisp salads, perfect for sit-down dinners or a grab-and-go lunch.

Weedsport may be a small town, but it’s lucky to have a spot like this—authentic, unfussy, and packed with heart. Whether you're just passing through or calling Cayuga County home, this pizza shop deserves a stop on your culinary map.

The story behind the dough at Nino's

There’s no shortcut to good pizza, and Nino’s NY Pizzeria knows that better than most. Their recipe? Keep it simple, use quality ingredients, and never rush the dough. The kitchen team gives their crust the proper rest time, resulting in a base that bakes to a perfect golden char without getting soggy beneath toppings.

That’s the kind of detail you don’t notice until you’ve had a slice somewhere else that just doesn’t stack up. Their cheese blend hits that rich, creamy note, and you can tell it’s not the budget stuff. What elevates the experience even more is how consistent they are—visit once or five times, and that flavor profile remains spot on.

Locals have shared stories about family pizza nights, post-game team dinners, or a spontaneous stop that turned into a weekly ritual. One guest even joked, “If I lived any closer, I’d be broke from ordering here every night.” And honestly? We get it.

Why travelers and locals keep coming back

When you walk into Nino’s, there’s a rhythm to the place. Orders fly in, the kitchen hustles, and the vibe is relaxed but alive. You’ll spot families sharing pies, solo diners digging into a personal pizza and Coke, and delivery drivers heading out with stacks of boxes.

And while pizza is the star, the supporting cast deserves praise too. The garlic knots—soft, buttery, dusted with parmesan—might just be the best in Cayuga County. Their subs are loaded, pressed, and toasted just right, and if you’re a fan of buffalo wings, theirs are crispy, spicy, and always hot.

Another big draw? The people. Friendly staff who remember your name, crack a joke, and treat every order like it matters. That kind of hospitality is harder to find than it should be these days, but Nino’s holds onto it tight.

What others are saying about Nino’s Weedsport

Look at the reviews, and a theme quickly appears—consistent praise for the quality, speed, and service. One frequent diner wrote, “Best pizza in the Finger Lakes region. Period.” Another pointed out how Nino’s catered their office party with no hiccups and rave reviews.

The place gets love from both regulars and out-of-towners, with many reviewers noting how they stumbled across it during a road trip and now make it a must-stop. Online platforms have dozens of photos showcasing towering slices, cheesy pulls, and packed dining tables. There’s even talk of it being a hidden gem for those exploring upstate New York eats.

For those wanting to plan a visit or call in an order, Nino's NY Pizzeria at 8889 S Seneca St Weedsport, NY 13166 is open most days until late. Parking is easy, and the dine-in space, while casual, is clean, cozy, and welcoming.

So whether you’re on the hunt for a solid pizza joint or simply want a bite that tastes like Brooklyn in the heart of Weedsport, Nino’s NY Pizzeria delivers—every single time.